March 25 2015
Government has failed to make a convincing case that HS2 will increase rail capacity or help to rebalance the economy, a stinging report from the House of Lords’ Economic Affairs Select Committee says today.
The Committee asks that the next Government must provide suitable answers to 16 questions (see below) before Parliament approves legislation that will allow work on HS2 to begin.
On the issue of capacity the Committee says that overcrowding on the West Coast Mainline is largely a problem confined to Friday evenings and weekends. Less expensive options to remedy these problems have, it claims, not been properly reviewed.
The Committee also disputes the claim that HS2 will help to rebalance the economy, saying that London would most likely be the biggest beneficiary of the project. There is a strong case, it adds, for building the northern legs of HS2 first or improving trans-Pennine links to help improve the northern economy before starting on the southern leg of HS2.
Cost per mile of building HS2 will be up to nine time higher than high speed line in France, the Committee says. If the project does go ahead costs could be reduced, it claims, by building the network to accommodate 200MPH trains as in Europe, rather than 250MPH trains. It also calls for the line to terminate at Old Oak Common, rather than Euston.
“At £50Bn HS2 will be one of the most expensive infrastructure projects ever undertaken in the UK but the Government has not yet made a convincing case for why it is necessary,” says the House of Lords’ Economic Affairs Select Committee chairman Lord Hollick. “The Committee is supportive of investment in rail infrastructure but is not convinced that HS2 as currently proposed is the best way to deliver that investment.
“We have set out a number of important questions on HS2 that the Government must now provide detailed answers to. Parliament should not approve the enabling legislation that will allow HS2 work to begin until we have satisfactory answers to these key questions.”
A Department for Transport spokesman said that the case for HS2 is “crystal clear” and the project will have a “transformational effect supporting growth in the north”.
“We have been fulIy transparent about the project,” the spokesman said. “HS2 will deliver over £2 of benefits for every £1 invested and the economic benefit of the project was recognised by MPs of all parties who voted 452 to 41 in favour of HS2 at the second reading of the Hybrid Bill.
“Demand for long distance rail travel has doubled in the past 15 years and without HS2 key rail routes connecting London, the Midlands and the north will soon be overwhelmed, stifling growth in towns and cities across the country. It is crucial we press ahead with delivering HS2 on time and budget and we remain on track to start construction in 2017.”
HS2 questions the next Government must answer:
National transport plan
The cost of HS2
Who will pay for HS2
Demand and capacity
Lack of consideration of alternative rail investment
Effect on the UK economy
Lack of evidence
Return to news listing
May 14 2015
CIHT welcomes the potential opportunity for transport to be given a greater strategic focus through the Cities Devolution Bill as giving greater prominence to transport can unlock wider benefits. Transport offers economic, social and health benefits, particularly in congested urban situations. Cycling and walking need to feature prominently in discussions about transport decision making, investment and management in city regions.
May 20 2015
February 23 2015
Department for Transport Questions
February 13 2015
New Issue of Transportation Professional Available
February 18 2015
Infrastructure Act's Royal Assent welcomed
Chancellor urged to increase certainty for local transport
February 26 2015
Local transport – its planning, funding and governance – has seen big changes in the last few years. Will this help local transport contribute more to economic growth and quality of life?
February 25 2015
Designs showcased for new London river crossing
Through ticketing urged to help international travellers
Call for more public involvement with infrastructure planning
February 24 2015
Professor Glen Lyons, CIHT Council Member, from the University of West of England secured a secondment to the New Zealand Ministry of Transport. In this podcast Glen outlines the scope of the project: “the real challenge was to combine how transport might develop with how society itself might develop…we are fundamentally embracing uncertainty”.
March 4 2015
Forth Bridge's 125 years of service celebrated
Drug drivers to be caught more easily under new law
Funding for city cycle projects announced by Government
Streamlined local highway arrangement suggested
Pay soars for construction workers on the railways
March 6 2015
Motoring of the Future
March 10 2015
Call for a National Transport Strategy at CIHT Annual Conference
March 11 2015
National Conference calls for greater devolution
Train services to resume after Harbury Tunnel landslip
Rail lines drawn to aid London growth
Transport group appoints new head
March 18 2015
The Construction Industry Council (CIC) has launched its election briefing this week.
2015 budgets highlights how transport is an engine for growth
Hopes that Easter rail works run smoothly
A5-M1 link road to benefit long distance traffic
Parties refuse to back forthcoming aviation report
March 20 2015
Northern Transport Strategy
March 25 2015
More clarity demanded of Northern transport strategy
Joint venture secures Newport M4 upgrade
March 24 2015
£275m Challenge Fund for local infrastructure - winning authorities announced
March 26 2015
ALARM survey highlights concerns over the state of the local road network
April 2 2015
April 1 2015
Highways England, the government-owned company which will deliver the largest investment in England’s major roads in a generation, officially launched today.
April 8 2015
April 10 2015
April issue of Transportation Professional Available.
April 13 2015
The Labour party has launched their 2015 election manifesto today, including a 5-point plan aimed at improving transport in the UK.
April 15 2015
April 14 2015
The Conservative party and the Green party have both unveiled their respective 2015 election manifestos today.
April 22 2015
April 17 2015
CIHT have analysed and reviewed the recent transport commitments in a number of political party manifestos released this week.
April 29 2015
May 6 2015
May 11 2015
Transport Minister Announcement
May 13 2015
May 27 2015
Queens Speech 2015
June 10 2015
June 3 2015
June 11 2015
Ministers from the Department for Transport answered oral questions in the Commons on 11 June.
Andrew Jones, new Minister for Local Roads has announced the ‘pilot exercise’ for the local highways maintenance funding incentive element.
June 19 2015
The June 2015 issue of Transportation Professional is now available for members of CIHT to view.
June 17 2015
June 18 2015
Highways England’s New Chief Executive
June 24 2015
June 25 2015
Network Rail upgrades to be delayed by government
July 1 2015
CIHT welcome the Davies Commission final report
July 8 2015
July 9 2015
An English Summer Budget: a CIHT Review
Chancellor of the Exchequer, George Osborne, announced a major change to the funding of England’s Strategic Roads Network (SRN) in the Budget.
July 10 2015
Government Outlines Productivity Challenge
July 15 2015
July 17 2015
July/August issue of Transportation Professional Available.
Ministers from the Department for Transport answered oral questions in the Commons on 16 July.
Fixing the foundations: commentary
July 22 2015
July 29 2015
July 31 2015
CIHT has an opportunity to put forward the thoughts and representations of its membership suggesting ideas for policies or reforms for inclusion in the Spending Review.
August 5 2015
August 6 2015
Transport can have a positive impact on the local economy, although the role of transport in stimulating growth is not as clear-cut as assumed by many decision makers is not as clear-cut assumed by many decision makers. This is the conclusion from a report produced by the What Works Centre for Local Economic Growth.
NE&C 2015 Awards - promotion and entry guidelines
August 12 2015
The National Audit Office (NAO) have recently published ‘A short guide to the Department for Transport’.